INTRODUCTION
Racial Group: Chinese Denomination: House Church (Unofficial or not recognized by the Chinese government)Region of the World: Mainland ChinaTwo main lines of investigation here: 1. The effect of European colonialism on China2. The birth of the House Church Movement under China's "local form of imperialism"Basic Information on House Church Movement in China:The Chinese government has implemented legislative sanctions to regulate religious activity by requiring all collective religious activities to be conducted at registered venues. As a non-compromising but non-confronting religious movement, some house churches enjoy a high degree of autonomy and ample room for expansion, though it is under close surveillance by local authorities and without legal status. "House churches" (家庭教會 jiating jiaohui) are one of the most sensitive issues relating to human rights, religious freedom and expansion of Christianity in China. They generally refer to Christian communities that conduct religious services without government approval in the homes of believers. By legislation, all religious activities must be conducted at venues registered for religious use and in a manner approved by the government (Cheng, 2003, 16).
"Jesus in China" A clip from the PBS series
that gives some basic information
Number of Chinese Christians in China:
The statistics regarding the number of Chinese Christians a part of the House Church Movement are inconsistent and difficult to obtain. Even mere estimates are nearly impossible to assess especially due to the secret and hidden nature of house church gatherings (Lambert 2003, 7). In 1998 a report issued by leaders of nine major house church networks claimed that there were 10 million Christians in the Three-Self churches and 80 million in house churches. But after considering the many various statistics and estimates made by church leadership, government officials, and researchers, Tony Lambert concludes that in order to gather accurate and reliable statistics regarding the number of Christians in China that worship in both registered and unregistered churches, a statistical survey of all cities, counties, and rural districts must be taken (Lambert 2003, 10). This would prove to be a very difficult task and until Chinese House churches become more public institutions, mere estimates will be the only source.
The Official Policy of the Chinese Communist Party on Religion in China (An Official Chinese Communist Party document regarding religion in China, from 1982): "The Basic Viewpoint and Policy on the Religious Question During Our Country's Socialist Period"
"Religion will eventually disappear from human history. But it will disappear naturally only through the long-term development of Socialism and Communism, when all objective requirements are met."
The stated goal of the Chinese Communist Party is a Marxist Socialism that would create a society in which religion is unneeded and irrelevant. In its ideology, the elimination of class struggles and oppression paves the way for a society void of Christianity, Buddhism, Islam, Daoism, Catholicism, and any other alternative forms of religious expression and belief. The Party is strictly atheist and requires its 70 million Party members to adhere to an atheistic set of beliefs and lifestyle. In regards to the remainder of the 1.6 billion people living in the borders of China, the Party emphatically maintains a policy of "freedom of religious belief," a phrase that has been ambiguously interpreted and questionably upheld by the Chinese government. Their policy reduces issues of religious faith and belief to individual decisions and private matters.
In order to provide its people with an environment suitable for practicing their individual faiths under the leadership of the Communist Party, they have created several "patriotic religious organizations."
"The basic task of these patriotic religious organizations is to assist the Party and the government to implement the policy of freedom of religious belief, to help the broad mass of religious believers and persons in religious circles to continually raise their patriotic and Socialist consciousness, to represent the lawful rights and interest of religious circles, to organize normal religious activities, and to manage religious affairs well. All patriotic religious organizations should follow the Party’s and government’s leadership."
The Three-Self Patriotic Movement is one of these organizations that governs the religious activities of all Protestant denominations and faiths. But due to the political nature of the Party's influence in the function of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement, many Christians in China refuse to submit to register themselves under the authority of this Communist-led organization and instead take part in the faith activities of the house churches (MacInnis 1989, 8-26).
It is not the desire of the Chinese to expose the cruelty of a regime as much as to tell of the love of Jesus Christ. They are not telling their story to get even with those who persecuted them, but to testify to the love and power of the One who saved them. ---Carl Lawrence(Lawrence, 1985)
|
"Jesus in China: Christianity's Rapid Rise" (Link) CPC seeks to eradicate religion.
(Link)Bill 144 and 145 passed by the Chinese government in 1982 and 1991which state actions against non-registered religious premises. (Link)
Video representation of the findings of this site.
UNIVERSALITY Description
The nature and position of the Chinese House Church as both a Christian institution and a non-approved, sometimes even threatened, body by the Chinese government prescribes that its members would all firmly hold to a set of beliefs and values deemed universal for all people. The primary universal is the religious right of every human being to choose his or her own religious and spiritual beliefs.1. Some universals that House Church Christians believe: - Believe that God is alive and active in China.
- Believe in the Holy Spirit and miracles.
- To be a Christian is to sacrifice (going against their culture, costs, need to dedicate and commit).
- Christians do not necessarily have services on Sundays.
- Christians do not necessarily realize the restrictions in their country. (Outsiders usually think that Chinese Christians know the restrictions they are facing in the country.) Their knowledge, e.g. church history in China, is limited.
2. Some universals that non-Christians in China believe about Christianity and /or House Church: - Christianity is Western. Why should I believe in a Western religion?
- Need to adhere to their ancestral religion as a respect to the elders in the family.
- Only the needy, the poor, the weak will become Christians.
3. Some universals that Christians outside China believe about House Church Christians: - Constantly under persecution
- Meet in underground, unexposed, remote condition
- Members are peasants or uneducated
- Mission means Back to Jerusalem Movement
Stories
Experience of a Chinese house church leader:
One summer afternoon, I had a chance to worship in a Chinese church in United States. After the worship, two elders of the church came up to talk with me.The first one who knew I was from Mainland China, asked sincerely about our situation in the Mainland. He urged me to be very careful because he read from the newspaper recently that Christians from one of the house churches were arrested by the government. I heard, from his words, sympathy and support for the house church, and criticism of the Chinese government. Another elder came to talk with me. He spoke of a time when he went back to Shanghai, he attended some activities of the Three Self Church. He had good impression of them. The Three Self Church also gave him an impression that they would very much like to accept the house churches, but the house churches were too sealed up that they would not want to reconcile with the Three Self Church. I heard, from his words, sympathy and acceptance of the Three Self Church, and bad impression on the “underground”, “sealed up”, “un-cooperative” house churches. From the one to two years of my association with overseas Chinese and Western churches, I begin to realize these two common attitudes towards Chinese house church. (Brother Suen: Chinese House Church Leader) Dreams
From Brother Suen who told the story above: He wants to share an insider's view of the Chinese House Church to help outsiders to know more correctly about them. (See under the heading "Difference" for his sharing.) DIFFERENCEDescription
A Different kind of Imperialism in China:
Imperializing texts written by the colonizing nations justified imperialism and the act of colonizers, and validated their authority over the colonized (Dube 2006, 299). China managed to keep most part of her country intact during the invasion of the European countries (except losing Hong Kong and Macau to the British and the Portuguese). Many years later, the Communist Chinese government seems to have learned from those who tried to colonize her. Though China is not a colonizer, she adopts similar tactics through propaganda literature and arts to impose her authority and control over everything which includes the practice of religious beliefs and religious premises. Recent regulations have loosened the grip a bit. But the overall mentality has not changed much. If imperialism is an ideology of expansion that seeks to control foreign nations (Ibid, 297), then the practice of the Communist China regime is a "local form of imperialism".
Effect of China’s “local form of imperialism” on Today’s House Church:
Anything that threatened the plans of the Chinese government was not tolerated. China’s “local form of imperialism” was fully expressed in her dealing with the "Tiananmen Square Protests“ in 1989. The hearts of many intellectuals were disillusioned after this. The incident actually prepared the hearts of many intellectuals in China to be opened to the Gospel. From the 1990s until now, different reports show a continue rise in the number of Bible study groups and fellowships in universities. And the number of young believers also increases. The Chinese government is greatly alarmed by this and takes action to increase education on Marxist ideology among universities students (Zeng 2006).
Houses churches in Beijing under China “local form of imperialism”:
81.54% of house churches in Beijing rent venues for their services. However, this has become an issue of their survival! Because a major method the Beijing government uses to restrict house churches is to use its power to stop the rent contracts, and kick the house churches out of the premises. Methods employ by the house churches to deal with this: - Rent another premise. Strength: the whole group can continue to meet together. Weakness: sometimes the new place is so far away that some Christians stop coming to the church.
- Break up into small groups that meet at homes. Strength: provide stable meeting place. Weakness: house churches become small and weak, scarce resources.
- Buy a premise under the personal name of one of the member. Strength: a stable meeting place. Weakness: expensive, may have dispute over whose name to be under. (Brother Liu: from Mainland China, now resides in California)
A Different Chinese House Church:
A new generation of Chinese House Church in the city: - Overseas churches shall not see Chinese House Church as always un-cooperative and passive in dealing with registration of their churches. Actually, some house churches are very active in seeking registration with the government. Many hope to be registered separately from the official Three Self Patriotic Movement (Riley).
- Chinese house churches do not only gather behind closed doors and windows. They are not only underground churches that play hide-n-seek with the government. A new generation of house churches in the cities is in the process of opening up themselves. They are more confident to establish constructive dialogue with the government.
- Nowadays house churches are seeking to establish a healthy church system rather than just relying on an old pastor. An organization from Hong Kong that trains house church leaders has added to their training program a course on “Church administration and system”.
- The biggest concern of Chinese house churches is not their rights from a political point of view. House churches also see the contribution they can have on the society by concerning the poor, setting examples on the value of marriage and family….(Brother Suen: Chinese House Church Leader)
Stories
I personally know a brother who establishes a house church in his home town. As the house church grew, he and other brothers and sisters decided to get registration in the Religious Bureau. The process was very complicated. But they decided to go ahead anyway for they thought that it would be beneficial for future growth of their church. After much effort to acquire documents and information that the Bureau needed, they sent in their application for registration. Their application was rejected. They did not give up. They continued to find out what was the problem, what other documents were needed, and appealed to the Bureau for re-consideration. This process went on for twelve years with numerous times of appeal!! And thank the Lord, because of their perseverance, the Bureau eventually gives them the registration. (told by a sister in Hong Kong who knows this brother for more than 15 years) Dreams
It is the dream of the Chinese house churches to share the Gospel with as many fellow Chinese as possible. Brothers and sisters of house churches want to be the light in the society, especially when moral is declining, injustice is prevailing, people are losing hope in what they previously believe, and China is growing in her power.It is our dream as the writers to give a true and up-to-date picture of China and the Chinese house churches, so that readers may discard their universalities. This is a much needed but difficult task since China is changing so fast, and the house churches are developing and transforming.REPRESENTATION AND RESISTANCEDescription A Discussion of BINARISMS
Within the Chinese House and the relevant history of China there are several binarisms that have played a key role in its formation and currently play a key role in its thriving state.
China's history is full of instances in which the binarism of colonizer/colonized is evident. As Western colonial powers entered China to exploit its resources and achieve its goals, the Chinese people defended their country and culture with much success. Even Western missionaries had great difficulty in their efforts to establish communities of Chinese Christians. But as the Communist Party took power and the People's Republic was officially established, the role of colonizer was assumed by the Chinese Communist Party. As it began to exercise its local form of imperialism on its own Chinese people, the Chinese House Church was growing underground.
Several binarisms that exist within the Chinese House Church itself are man/woman, older/younger, and teacher/pupil. All three of these particular binarisms are born out of the Chinese culture as a whole. Traditional gender roles in the wider Chinese society are evident in the House Church movement today. Most house church leaders are males as females provide supporting roles in the churches' affairs. There are, however, many women who are pastoring house churches in China. This is a recent trend that may have developed due to the dramatic increase of female Christians in China. The remaining binarisms, that of older/younger and teacher/pupil, find their foundations in the ancient Chinese value of respect. Children, students, and younger generations are expected to grant proper respect to parents, teachers, and elder generations. Authority and wisdom is immediately conferred to those who are of greater age. This expectation of respect is still very present in the House Church Movement today.
Other forms of binarisms regarding the Chinese House Church Movement are not as much present within it but outside of it. There is a clear distinction in China between the Chinese House Church and the Three-Self Patriotic Movement. Distancing themselves from this Communist-controlled and government regulated Three-Self Church, many House Church leaders and members are unwilling to include themselves under the umbrella of Communist leadership. This distinct separation and division will continue to be evident in the future developments of the Chinese House Church's relationship with both its surrounding society and its Communist government.
The Chinese House Church has formed within the context of resistance against the theoretical and actual policies and positions of the Communist government. It has continued to resist the imperialistic nature of the Communist Party and its leadership. As aforementioned, the official religious position of the Communist Party is atheistic. Inherent in this situation is the potential for conflict and confrontation between the Chinese House Church and Communism. Though the Chinese House Church is a threat to the government's control over China, it is only a part of the actualized threat that the Party fears. They view the most significant threats to its power as counterrevolutionaries which include all those who are of intellectual, political, or religious in nature. The Chinese House Church is one of those threats.
For many years, the House Church has been given little representation within its society and government. Because the Three-Self Patriotic Church is the official state church and the Chinese House Church has operated as a rogue institution, Christian representation has only been granted to the Three-Self institutions. Bishop K.H. Ting, who has been the leader of the China Christian Council (the central voice of Christianity within the Chinese government) and Chairperson of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement is the individual with the loudest voice. The Chinese House Church, while operating underground for much of its existence to protect itself from persecution, has had little influence until recently.
Stories
In China today, there are still instances of punishment and persecution for the most influential House Church leaders. Thought not widely publicized, stories of the threatened safety, apprehension, and even physical brutality occasionally circulate around the globe. Those who endure this suffering are not only Chinese House Church leaders but also other officials or lawyers who have chosen to speak up on behalf of human rights and religious freedom. There continue to be consequences for those who choose to voice their thoughts, beliefs, and opinions in resistance to Communist Party ideology, policy, and practice.
Dreams
The future of the Chinese House Church as a part of Chinese society will undoubtedly continue to face opposition as it operates amidst resistance between itself and the government. There has been great hope recently as the Chinese House Church is beginning to experience more and more freedom from the Communist Party. Although much progress has been made since the Cultural Revolution, there is still much more ground that needs to be covered. As the voice of the Chinese House Church loudens and its influences among the people grows, its government and society will be forced to listen and pay attention to what is being said. NATIONALISM, EDUCATION, HISTORY Description
1. Introduction
Frantz Fanon defines national culture as "the whole body of efforts made by a people in the sphere of thought to describe, justify, and praise the action through which that people has created itself and keeps itself in existence" (Fanon 1995, 155). Nationalism is the ideology that informs the political and social construct that perpetuates and sustains the the nation. Chinese nationalism stands in a causal relationship with both types of imperialism in China. On the one hand, Western imperialism has largely been the impetus to strengthen Chinese nationalism in resistance against it. On the other hand, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) as used Chinese nationalism to keep itself in power by means of a local form of imperialism (Ibid,157). In seeking to define itself as a nation, communist China attempted to purge itself of all foreign elements, especially Western culture. In examining both lines of investigation, this section will examine the interaction of Chinese nationalism and both forms of imperialism and how these impacted the Church in China from the 1920s and the rise of Chinese nationalism until the 1970s, investigating the Cultural Revolution more deeply as the paradigm for these interactions.2. The Rise of Chinese NationalismThe 1920’s was a critical decade for Christianity in China. During this time, Chinese nationalistic aspirations grew stronger and began to resist Christianity as an arm of Western Imperialism. “The upheavals of the 1920s changed Christianity from being seen by many Chinese (including many non-Christians) as progressive, modern, and a desirable part of China’s future to being targeted as just another part of the hated foreign imperialist presence in China” (Bays 2003b, 146). These currents made it difficult for Chinese Christian leaders who were both devoted to their faith and their country.From the founding of the Chinese Republic until 1930, China lacked a strong centralized government. The Chinese nationalistic movement sought to build a strong centralized state and rid China from domination by foreign powers (Yip 2003, 134). The Chinese Nationalist party (Guomindang, GMD) under the leadership of Chiang Kai-shek sought to unify the country in the late 20s. However, internal weaknesses, corruption, and ambiguities within party policy plagued the GMD (Ibid, 136). During this time Western missionaries taught and practiced the "social gospel" through their charitable work in Christian hospitals, schools, and other institutions such as the YMCA. During the war with Japan (1937-1945) and the Communist Revolution, Chinese Christians began to favor this over the gospel of "individual salvation" because of "the efficacy of Christian social activism in dealing with the overwhelming human tragedy in the country" (Ibid, 141). This led many Chinese Christian leaders, who had socialist leanings, to accept Communism as consistent with Christian teachings, laying the groundwork for the formation of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM).3. The Marriage of Church and State: The Rise of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM)Ironically, the TSPM drew its principles from a Westerner, John Nevius, a Presbyterian missionary to China in the 19th Century. An innovator, Nevius had in mind that the Church in China should eventually be independent of the Western influence be becoming self-propagating, self-governing, and self-supporting. However, most Western missionaries did not share Nevius' vision and were dominated by paternalistic attitudes toward their Chinese converts until the accession of the Communist Party in 1949. In spite of this in the first half of the 20th Century, indigenous churches, such as the "True Jesus" Church and "Little Flock" arose independent of Western influence, truly operating under three-self principles (Bays 1996, 308). Despite the fact that many of these churches did not survive, their creativity and energy provided a foundation for the future leaders of the house church movement (Bays 1996, 316).
Although he was and is highly criticized by conservative evangelical Christians both in China and abroad, Y.T. Wu (former Chinese YMCA leader and new leader of the TSPM) may have contributed to the Church’s survival during the early years in Communist China (Gao 1996, 343). In 1950, under Wu’s leadership, the TSPM drew up the “Christian Manifesto,” which attempted to set the tone for Church-State relations for the new government. “The Christian Manifesto took as its principal theme anti-imperialism, and stressed ‘the fact that in the past imperialism has made use of Christianity,’ and the necessity to ‘purge imperialistic influences from within Christianity itself’” (Ibid, 344). While the document did not condemn Christianity as imperialistic per se, it did lament many of its imperialistic ties. Even though it scandalized many Chinese Protestant leaders, its positive tone on the future of Church-State relations in China ill-prepared Christians for the persecution that was to come (Ibid, 345).The TSPM gradually became the only Chinese Church authority. In 1958 it forced the dissolution of all Protestant Denominations, combining them into one under the control of the TSPM (Ibid, 347). This unnatural unification, which occurred in conjunction with “The Great Leap Forward,” Mao Tse Tung’s first great experiment of forced communization, devastated the Protestant Church, greatly reducing the number of churches and worshippers, but it provided the initial impetus to the formation of the underground house church movement (Ibid, 347). 4. The Cultural RevolutionThe Cultural Revolution began from a dispute within Beijing in 1965 as Chairman Mao suggested a return to the policies of the “Great Leap Forward.” Although the majority of Party elites opposed this decision, Mao and other leaders vilified them and appealed to the masses, “depending instead on the majority of the armed forces and on the spontaneous organization of secondary school pupils and students.” (Domes 1977, 10). This plunged the country into the “Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution” that lasted from 1966 until Mao’s death in 1976. Thus the Cultural Revolution carried out Mao’s ideology under the guise of his desire to remain in power.
While many countries that were subjected to Western imperialism looked to their pre-colonial past to build national pride and revive their nation in resistance to the colonial powers, (Fanon 1995, 154) China looked not to their past but to an optimistic view of the future under the rule of Communist Party leader Mao Tse Tung. The Cultural Revolution was unleashed to wipe out undesirable elements of Chinese culture. This included bourgeois, Western, imperialist, and much of the old cultural heritage of China itself including icons of the old feudal order and Chinese religions--Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism. “The first and most dramatic phase of the Cultural Revolution was the explosive red guard movement of 1966-68. In a manner unprecedented in communist-ruled states, young middle school and university students were unleashed to attack cultural symbols of the old society, academic representatives of ‘bourgeois’ scholarship, and party leaders allegedly infected with revisionist ideas. In most instances, the red guard movement quickly fractured into fiercely conflicting factions…” (Esherick 2006, 19). Under the guise of patriotism, Mao unleashed the nationalistic fervor of the masses by his call to revolution.In 1940 Mao Tse Tung had written an essay “On New Democracy" which "sounded the death knell of old culture: ‘Reactionary culture serves the imperialists and the feudal class and must be swept away. Unless it is swept away, no new culture of any kind can be built up. There is no construction without destruction, no flowing without damming, and no motion without rest; the two are locked in a life and death struggle'” (Ho 2006, 66). Motivated by Mao’s call, the Red Guard’s “crusade to wipe out China’s ‘old thought, old culture, old customs and old habits’ continued nationwide for over a year.” This included destroying or damaging many of China’s historical sites, including “valuable classics, paintings, and antiques (Ibid, 65). With the Cultural Revolution Maoist ideology had come to fruition. In an effort to remove his adversaries, he called for the rebuilding of a new Chinese culture through the destruction of the old. Mao’s use of binarisms demonstrate the false notion that Communism is the antithesis of imperialism and that it would free China from the evils imposed on it by the Western Imperial powers, for the Cultural Revolution demonstrated that “Reactionary Culture” (old imperialism) is not the antithesis of “Revolutionary Culture” (Communist imperialism) since both result in violence, terror, and the oppression of people.
As the Cultural Revolution raged, the Red Guard became disenfranchised with with Maoist ideology, preferring a more pure form of communism. Mao turned the PLA (People’s Liberation Army) on the Red Guards to put down this phase of the Cultural Revolution in which armed conflicts were fought from 1967-1969. Mao “wanted to remove the opponents of his policies from the decision-making bodies, to fill the political system with new revolutionary enthusiasm, thereby raising the political consciousness of the masses to a new and higher level” (Domes 1977, 18). However, that new enthusiasm and political consciousness had formed anarchic mobs that were tearing China apart in an effort to remove the old bureaucratic order. While the attacks of the Red Guards brought about a lot of damage, it more often damaged property than people. The greatest number of fatalities during the Cultural Revolution was the result of organized mass killings from 1968-1971. These were largely preemptive attacks on state enemies and “bad elements” of society and were ordered by the state or village militia (Esherick 2006, 21).
Young people waving the "Little Red Book" (Quotations from Chairman Mao) at Mao during one of the Cultural Revolution parades
5. The Chinese Church Interprets the TimesAfter 1950, all Protestant Denominations were dissolved and Christian churches were supposed to be run by the Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM). Instead of an ecumenical movement, this forced consolidation had disastrous effects on the Church (Gao 1996, 347). Under the pretext of nationalism and church unity, from 1949-1958 churches were gradually closed, their pastors were murdered or imprisoned as counterrevolutionaries (Lawrence 1985, 35). Many refused to join the TSPM churches and began to meet in homes; however, Some Christians regarded the Cultural Revolution as “the Tribulation” from Revelation (Ibid, 29). Many Christians also considered it a time of church purification and the sowing of seeds (Ibid, 35). Stories
Story from the period of rising Chinese Nationalism: The life of Chen Chonggui reflects how Western-style education helped some of China’s poorest achieve success, but also the tension felt in China by many Chinese Christians who fought for Chinese independence from Western Imperialism only to fall into the arms of the domestic imperialism of the Chinese Communist Party.Chen Chonggui was born into a poor family in 1884. He grew up as a Christian in the Covenant Mission. A hard worker, intellectual, and gifted speaker, Chen devoted his life to God and became a teacher at a Covenant Seminary in Hubei Province. Fueled by his strong, conservative, evangelical faith as well as a conviction that the Chinese Church should be Chinese-led, Chen at times offended his Western Christian benefactors by his unwillingness to remain a secondary leader under their control. From the 1920s until the 40s Chen oversaw publication of a local evangelical magazine, toured as a public speaker, both in China and abroad, and eventually partnered with the China Inland Mission (CIM) who helped him become President of a new seminary in Chongqing, Sichuan Province. Since he was committed both to Chinese autonomy of the Church and non-denominationalism, Chen became one of the chairpersons of the Three Self Party Movement (TSPM). As one of the most conservative members of the TSPM, he spoke out against Communist Party for its poor treatment of Christians in the initial years of Communist Party rule in spite of the religious freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution when the Party sought criticism during the “Hundred Flowers Campaign of 1957.” The “Anti-Rightist Movement” that followed landed many of the critics in labor camp, but for Chen, who was in his 70s by then, he was simply removed from his post and slipped into obscurity until his death in 1963 (Bays 2003, 155). Unlike other Christian leaders who supported the draconian policies of the CCP and TSPM, Chen is remembered for his life of devotion to the work of the Lord.Story from the Great Leap Forward: A pastor called “Mr. Wang” “He was arrested in March 1958, almost eight years before the infamous Cultural Revolution. He was sent to a labor camp for ten years of ‘reeducation.’ His crime: being a professing Christian who refused to deny his faith. In the labor camp, he continued to profess his faith and to witness among his fellow prisoners. He was dealt with very severely, receiving the worst possible jobs, very little medical care and a minimum supply of food rations. He would be placed in a cell with others whose job it was to make him recant his belief in Jesus Christ. His cell-mates would also receive extra labor and small rations until such time as they ‘convinced’ the ‘comrade’ to denounce his faith. He didn’t, and they killed him" (Lawrence 1985, 36).Dreams
Chinese Nationalism is being redefined as the growing economy adopts capitalist principles. Christians also seek to redefine Chinese nationalism in a way that incorporates the Christian faith. A Christian businessman who was a former Communist party member wrote, "'the market economy discourages idleness. [But] it cannot discourage people from lying or causing harm. A strong faith discourages dishonesty and injury.' Christianity and the market economy, in his view, go hand in hand.” (Sons of Heaven, 2008). He believes Christians serve a vital role in Chinese society. Christianity forms a basis for good citizens. While they oppose unjust policies, such as the one-child policy, Christianity does not pose a political threat. His dream for China is that an economy characterized by the open market and Christian ethics be incorporated into Chinese nationalism.HYBRIDITY, INDIGENEITYDescription
Hybridity:
There is a parallel between the hybrid identity of the people of Hong Kong in the postcolonial time and that of the return scholars (university graduates who go back to China after their overseas studies) who contribute to probably the latest house church movement as they establish Bible study groups and house churches of their own kind. In Lee's essay, he compares the Israeli exilic community in the Book of Isaiah with the community of Hong Kong in the postexilic situation (ie. after Hong Kong returns to China). Among the Israeli returnees, there were those who wanted to integrate their new experience in Babylon with their old tradition. And this created a future for the faith of Israel (Lee 2006, 291). They adopted the hybridity strategy (Ibid, 286). For people in Hong Kong, the hybridity strategy is to strive for autonomy by seeking wider participation in HKSAR (Hong Kong Special Administrative Region), to embrace the Chinese culture, as well as incorporating their histories as a British colony (Ibid, 291). This calls for the vision of “an open, inclusive community that can embrace plurality and facilitate the integrity of humanity” to sustain such community (Ibid, 292).A parallel of the above can be seen in Chinese Christian return scholars who are hybrids with new experience and old tradition. Most of them become Christians when they study overseas. They have influence from foreign culture. Their love for China and the hope of building China with good Christian values bring them back from overseas. However, they are unsatisfied with the churches under the Three Self Patriotic Movement or house churches which make up of mostly peasants and workers. They willingly embrace China, yet hope for autonomy in their faith. So they establish their own Bible study group of house churches and are reaching out to other intellectuals. It calls for an open, inclusive government and its Religious Bureau to accommodate them!
Indigeneity:
Characteristics of house churches: 1. The house churches are indigenous.
They are not associated with any organization and certainly have no formal ties with the church outside China. The vast majority of new believers has been the result of indigenous evangelization. They are not associated with Western imperialism. Without any organizational structure, they are not bound by committee meetings, reports, and the power politics common in organized churches. They are also free from control by any national organization (Adeney 1985, 146).
2. The house churches are rooted in family units. Many Christians meet only with family members and close friends. Two or mature Christian families would look for a family that is just approaching Christian faith and would provide support for them. The believing community is built up with little clusters of Christian families (Ibid, 147).
3. The house churches are stripped of nonessentials. They exist without buildings, set times of worship, or a paid ministry. The place of meeting is often changed from one home to another. Even the time is changed to suit the schedules of the Christians as they work at different hours. The house churches are extremely flexible (Ibid, 148).
4. The house churches emphasize the lordship of Christ With Jesus as the head of the body, the church places obedience to him above any other loyalty; it does not accept control by any outside organization (Ibid, 148).
5. The house churches depend on lay leadership. The ministry is made up of people from various walks of life who spend much time going from church to church teaching and building up the faith of others. The house churches are not allowed to take up offerings for the support of full-time workers, but the Christians do contribute to those who have been called by God to exercise the ministry of the Word through these faithful visits (Ibid, 158).

Reasons for the rise of Chinese House Church in the city since 1990s: - 1. “Tiananmen Square Protests” prepared the hearts of many intellectuals in China to be open to the Gospel.
- 2. A consumer product economy let Chinese realize that they have a freedom of choice.
- 3. The effect of an increased rate of urbanization in China.
- 4. Return of overseas graduates who become Christians when they study overseas, and are now coming back to China
- to serve the Lord (Zhu n.d.).
Stories
Story from Cheng Du, China:
Brother and Mrs. Peng returned to China to pastor a house church after they graduated from Bible Seminary overseas. Brother Wang established a fellowship. The fellowship is gradually become a house church. Brother Wang became a Christian for two to three years. There are about 40 churches like these in the city of Cheng Du (Ibid).Story from Nan Jing, China:
After Brother Ji left an official Bible Seminary and the Three Self Church, he established a house church. After some years, the house church is becoming quite established. There are also student fellowships that are gradually changing to becoming house churches. One of them that is originally a small house church has developed into four house church groups. Another house church established by a Brother Yang has four to five hundred people gathering for worship services (Ibid).
Dreams
It is the dream of the overseas Chinese Christian intellectuals to return and contribute to their beloved Motherland. They have received the love and grace from the Lord and would very much like to share with their fellow countrymen, especially those that have a similar background as theirs.
ETHNICITY, RACE (Minority People Groups in China) Description Composition of people groups in China Within the Peoples’ Republic of China there are 56 recognized people groups, ethnic groups, or nationalities. The people groups consist of Han, which is the largest single group, and 55 minority groups, which compromise seven percent of the population of China. Archaeologists and anthropologists have concluded that the Chinese have descended from four ancient ethnic groups: Yanhuang, Miaoman, Baiye, and Dongyi, making the Chinese not one distinct race but a blend of existing tribal people groups (Chao 1989, 387).
Localities and influence by Chinese Authorities The homelands of many of thenational minority people groups are located along China’s borders. Historically, many of these areas were controlled or ruled by China only at times, off and on; frequently the control was tenuous, more a matter of influence than direct rule. Even in recent decades, on the eve of the Communist revolution of 1949, some of these domains were, realistically speaking, beyond the reach of the Chinese authorities. The government today asserts that these areas, such as Tibet, have “always” been part of China, but that is political rhetoric, not historical fact (Gunde 2002, 10).
Christianity and Minority groups
Among the 55 national minorities, which number over 100 million, and inhabit areas constituting about 60 per cent of China’s territory, mainly in strategic border areas, some of these ethnic groups responded very favourably to Christianity before the communist period, such as the Hua Miao. In Christian conversion it seems that some minorities found social and psychological resources to resist domination and oppression by both the Han majority and by other minorities, and others found reinforcement for traditional cultural or religious identities. Some minorities that had substantial numbers of Christians were strikingly loyal to their faith despite persecution after 1949. There has always been a widely varying pattern in the willingness of some minority groups and the unwillingness of others to convert to Christianity. In the recent and present situation in China, the minorities who inhabit inaccessible interior areas in the south-west are being bypassed by the national movement towards modernization, and moreover are often victims of extreme poverty, drug addiction and social breakdown. Some of these groups have been very receptive to Christianity. Moreover, some county governments in these areas, in an ironic reversal of the past stance of government vis-a`-vis religion, but desperate to combat the drug problem and its dangers to public health and law and order, have actively promoted the conversion to Christianity of the afflicted peoples, and have facilitated their evangelization by Chinese Christians (Bays 2003a, 497).
A brief information of each minority group with the percentage of Christians
* The data in the table below is from two books: Jonathan Chao, The China Mission Book (Hong Kong: Chinese Church Research Center: 1989), 141-195, and Paul Hattaway, Operation China: Introduction all the Peoples of China (Pasadena, CA: Piquant, 2000), 15-574.
* The population and the rate of Christians are based on the measure on 2000 and abbreviators are used to save space.
Stories
According to Covell, one of the factors that led to evangelism among minority groups in China is indigenous people's effort on bring their people groups into the Christian faith. A brief story of one of the persons is told here. "Among the Sediq in Taiwan, the key person was a middle-aged woman by the name of Jiwang. Relatively uneducated, she had many qualities which prepared her for being the initiator of a people movement to the Christian faith, which in turn was a catalyst to faith among several other Taiwan minorities. She was open to the outside world beyond her tribal roots, she was an astute business woman, she was chosen by the Japanese government to be the reconciler between the officials and her people, and when she become a Christian, she knew how to instruct her compatriots in the basics of the Christian faith. She was not daunted by the persecution that came to her as a result of her commitment." (Covell 2001)
Dreams
The minority peoples and missionAs seen in the table above, 11 minorities have no Christians. 7 groups are highly Christianized at at least 16%. In 27 minorities, there are only fewer than 10% of Christians. With this measure, the percentage of Christians among the 55 minority groups is lower than 5% on average, approximately equal to the largest ethnic group, the Han, which is only 4.72% Christians. The most qualified people to reach out to these minorities are the members of the Chinese House Church because they are more familiar with their culture and better able to travel to those remote parts of China where minorities live.HISTORY, PLACEDescription "The history of modern China is a history of imperialist aggression, of imperialist opposition of China's independence and to her development of capitalism."
-Mao Zedong |
History of Christianity in ChinaThe history of Christianity in China can generally be divided into 4 periods of time and stretches all the way back to the 600s (Brander 2004, 199). Evidence of an Assyrian/Nestorian church dating back to 638 AD is located in the ancient imperial capital city of the Tang Dynasty, Xian (Joseph). Because this Christian monument is located in the heart of the Tang empire, there is speculation that Christianity could have been a large factor in the ancient Chinese culture of that time, but there is little evidence outside of this Nestorian church that indicates that Christianity thrived during this period. The second period of Christianity, a period led by Roman Catholicism, began in the 16th century when Jesuit missionaries came to China . Their chief aim was to convert the emperor and other high-ranking influential leaders in hopes that the rest of the empire would do the same. Because the emperor was unwilling to bow to the pope, a figure of foreign authority, and because of conflicts within the Roman Catholic Church, these Jesuit missionaries were unsuccessful and had little impact (Ibid, 200).
As a result of the shameful Opium War (1839-1842) and the unequal Treaty of Nanking, the colonial forces of the West, primarily Britain, opened China hyperinflation and corruption, the Nationalist government was defeated by the Communists in 1949 and Mao Zedong proclaimed the People's Republic of China (Chao 1989, 8). The removal of foreign missionaries from China quickly followed. This marks both the end of the Protestant mission period and the beginning of the independent development of the Chinese church (Brandner 2004, 200). During the 1950s, the new Communist government was quite successful at dealing with the disastrous economic legacy of the previous 50 years and it instituted positive reforms such as ending prostitution and opium addiction, passing the Marriage Law, and giving a new dignity to women who had a low status in traditional Chinese society. In 1958, Mao Zedong, the supreme leader of the Communist Party, launched the disastrous “Great Leap Forward”, which caused millions to starve to death over the following three years. And in 1966 Mao claimed the start of the “Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution,” which is now referred to as the “ten years of calamity” by the Chinese people (Chao 1989, 7). It was during the Cultural Revolution that all forms of public worship and religious activities were banned (Brandner 2004, 200). In the ten years before Mao's death in 1976, China was swept by successive political campaigns with each one putting forth new targets for criticism and “class struggle” by the masses. The economy deteriorated dramatically (Chao 1989, 7). After Mao's death Deng Xiaoping began to lead the Communist Party in 1978 and under his leadership the emphasis of national policy moved away from “class struggle,” which formerly had been Mao’s primary concern, and toward's the “Four Modernizations”-- the modernization of agriculture, industry, science and technology, and defense. Through the “Open Door Policy,” China hoped to acquire the advanced technology, expertise and foreign currency which she needed for economic development. But with this kind of policy, China’s communist leaders have been threatened by the increased development among the people of democracy, individualism and religion (Ibid, 8). And finally in 1979, official state churches reopened under the Three-Self Patriotic Movement (Chao 1989, 11).The leadership of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement and its counterpart the Chinese Christian Council officially announced in 2002 that there were approximately 15 million Protestant Christians in China, a number that is 20 times greater than that in 1949. Much of this unprecedented growth occurred has within house churches during the past 30 years, its beginning marked by the early reforms of Deng Xiaoping (Lambert 2003, 7). 

Modern Chinese HistoryAfter Chinese Communist Party (CCP) took over China in 1949, the CCP made the new religious policies of the state (Chao 1989, 36-41). The CCP believed that religion is the opiate of the people and the state became hostile against the churches. The CCP and the church leaders adopted The Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM) (Ibid.). The TSPM tolerated churches to some degree and started controlling over Chinese churches. As the result of new policies, foreign mission movements have stopped and indigenous Chinese House Churches have been under persecution. The last foreign missionaries were expelled in 1951. The three steps of TSPM was nationalization, instrumentalization, and total extermination (Ibid.). The first step of the TSPM was nationalization by exterminating Western influences, including Western religions (Ibid.). The second step was instrumentalization by persecuting Christians, who were not yielding to the state (Ibid.). Church attendance has significantly declined at the end of the 1950s. During the Cultural Revolution (1996-76), the CCP did not have religious tolerance and all church activities have prohibited in China (Ibid.). The state’s ultimate goal was eradicating Christianity. Chinese House Church has been built by a lay movement, probably in the mid-1950s (Ibid.). In 1956, the state prohibited TSPM church leaders to attend house gatherings (Ibid.). And Chinese Christians started to go underground, where there had been strong Christian movement even before 1949 (Ibid.). From 1950s to the late 1970s, Chinese House Church was operated underground in order to avoid persecution (Ibid.). Each house church has unique story of origin. The number of Chinese House Church is estimated about 30 to 50 millions by Chinese church leaders (Ibid.). However, it is hard to estimate accurate figures of Chinese House Church. Chinese House Church has grown enormously under the severe persecutions. YouTube above: Mao Announcing the Establishment of People's Republic of China on October 1, 1949.
The Development of Chinese House Church
The Preparation Stage:There existed house meetings by independent churches before 1949. The Jesus Family, The True Jesus Church, The Little Flock, and The Christian Tabernacle had the house meetings in the Pre-Cultural Revolution period (Sing 2005, 87-88). These house meetings became the foundation for Chinese House Church (Ibid.).The Underground Stage:At the beginning of the Cultural Revolution, the house meetings were held secretly under the severe persecutions (Ibid., 89). The Development Stage:After the death of Mao Zedong in 1976, Deng Xiaoping renewed the TSPM policy with more religious toleration. Deng’s policy was the Four Modernizations (Ibid., 91). And the jailed church leaders have released. It was a golden era of Chinese House Church. However, in 1983, Document 19 became the new religious policy. Document 19 was reacting against the “uncontrollable” development of the church (Ibid.). And Chinese house churches have faced in a new era. The Organizational Stage:Document 19 required the house church meetings to be registered, letting the state know who they are (Ibid., 93). After the announcement of Document 19, Chinese House Church became more organized in terms of training, educating and church planting (Ibid.). The Mission Stage:Chinese House Church experienced enormous growth in the 1990s and house church leaders started to communicate with the state (Ibid.). Chinese House Church has focused on missions and strengthened the relationship with Western churches. And in the late 1990s, “the Back to Jerusalem Movement” has resumed (Ibid., 94). The TCPM and the House Church Movement started to emerge (Ibid.). Stories
A story from the Cultural Revolution: “One time we were holding a meeting of our Christian co-workers, over 300 pastors from different cities and towns. It was to be a three-day meeting. When the Red Guard found out about it, they began to send out secret police to see what was going on. We did not know this. During the meeting, we were praying and the Lord spoke to one of us, saying, ‘The situation here is very dangerous and the secret police are coming to arrest you.’ Quietly and one by one, all 300 pastors left the meeting by different ways. As soon as the last one was gone, the Red Guard surrounded the building. They were waiting for the 300 pastors to leave so they could arrest them. No one left the building. The Red Guard became impatient and were ready to break down the door. To their surprise, they found it ajar. The room was empty. The Red Guard leader exclaimed more in amazement than anger, ‘These Christians are different. They know exactly everything that we are doing.’ They left shaking their heads, but no doubt what had happened had made a deep impression on them” (Lawrence 1985, 37).DreamsThe Chinese House Church has experienced severe persecution throughout its history. However, Chinese Christians respond to suffering in away that is different and surprising to many Westerners. They acknowledge and bear suffering with a joyful heart as part of God's purpose (Sing 2005, 343). Through this suffering, the Chinese House Church has been trained for its unique mission (Ibid.). The dream of Chinese Christians is to send missionaries to most of the Muslim countries and fulfill the vision of "Back to Jerusalem Movement," by proclaiming the gospel along the ancient silk road trade route that linked China with the Middle East and Europe. They believe that God has called them to this mission because persecution of Christians is common in many Muslim countries in Asia. Also, as Asians, the Chinese are better able to relate to the people of Central Asia and the Middle East because they are more familiar with the customs and able to communicate the Gospel. So the Chinese House Church is uniquely suited and prepared for this mission!
FEMINISM
Description
Feminism is characterized by its commitment to bringing equality to the sexes in all phases of life. Feminism is an, “ongoing process of decolonizing culture" (Katrak 1995, 240) where “women in formerly colonized societies were doubly colonized by both imperial and patriarchal ideologies" (Petersen 1995, 233). While Western colonization for the most part was avoided by China, the Chinese people still experienced a local form of imperialism in which, women similar to Western women experienced a twofold effect because of the added patriarchal ideologies. Traditional Chinese women were oppressed and exploited in at least three major areas: “(1) family and marriage; (2) social and economic position; and (3) self-identification” (Ng 1988, 210). This movement towards equality in China cannot be discussed without mentioning the impact Christianity has had on it. Unfortunately one of the challenges in researching this is that most of the books, research and studies on this have been done from a male perspective. “Even when they mention mission for women, they emphasize the work ‘done for’ Chinese women, instead of telling the stories and lives of the women themselves. Chinese Scholars, too, have tended to focus more on Chinese men, who could write and therefore leave us with so-called ‘reliable’ historical data (Kwok 1988, 177). Nevertheless, even with scarce resources the goal is to piece together an accurate depiction of the deep impact Christianity has had on society and the women’s movement. Though this page is dedicated to the House Churches much of what will be said in this section will deal primarily with feminism and the church prior to the house church movement followed by how women played and continue to play an essential role in the House Churches. The reason for this is that a great deal of influence the church has had on feminism was prior to the persecutions that lead to the birth of the House Church. Women’s response to the GospelThe first official missionary conference held in China was in 1877 and from that conference there was an estimated 4,967 female Christians. About 100 years after what many may consider the first Chinese female convert, Mrs. Liang Fa, the female Christians had increased to 128,704 about 37% of the Protestant population (Kwok 1996, 194)
. In the International Journal of Frontier Missions article in 2004 it was reported that during the last 50 years the number of Christians has expanded to about 90 million with about 70% to 80% of that being female. One can only speculate the reason for such openness from women to the gospel; nevertheless a large debt of gratitude is owed to foreign women missionaries who started coming in larger numbers to china during the late 1800’s. Perhaps it was through their sacrificial ministry which in many ways helped pave the way for the movement towards equality that attracted women. Christian Women’s Contribution towards Equality Initially, many of those who became Christians came from poor and lower classes. The Church was able to serve many of these women by teaching them how to read as well as employing women to teach the bible. This was perhaps the preliminary steps towards equality since traditionally education and formal teaching positions were not the social norm for women at the time. From this, Christian women have continued to make an impact on elevating the consciousness of inequalities as well as the dignity and worth of women in society: - 1874 – Chinese Christian women took their first organized stance against social inequality by forming an anti-foot-binding movement (Kwok 1996, 204).
- 1879 – Chinese women gained access to medical training at Canton Hospital. Christian women were involved in introducing new conception of the women’s body which would eventually shatter the centuries-old myths and taboos surrounding such things as menstruation, pregnancy, and childbirth (Ibid, 205).
- 1886 – Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was introduced to China. This group participated in social reform activities such as public lectures and distribution of literature on the evils of foot-binding, polygamy, prostitution, and the selling of daughters into slavery (Lewis 2004, 194).
- 1920’s – The YWCA raises the Churches social and political consciousness by drawing attention to the injustice done to women working in factories and sweatshops. “YWCA literacy classes for workers in shanghai cotton mills had the lasting effect of raising the consciousness of female workers and nurturing female leaders in the labor movement" (Kwok 1996, 206).
| “Christianity is a motivating force which arouses women’s self-consciousness. This is evident in the past history of our country. When Christianity was introduced to China, education was provided for girls alongside with the churches. Women, who had for a long time accustomed to the unequal social teachings, became aware of their own status, and re-evaluate their worth as human beings. Emancipated form the families, they also demanded opportunity for economic independence and other women’s rights. This was the beginning of the women’s movement in China" -Sun Wenxue (Kwok 1988, 178) |
Role of Women in the House Church Ironically, while Christianity was making an impact on the women’s movement in society, within her own walls the church did not allow for the ordination of women. Despite the fact that women were not allowed to undergo the ordination process and formally learn how to lead this would provide to be the fertile soil in which women would have to learn and create their own networks, hold their own conferences (which met in houses), and discover their own leadership style independent of the Western pattern. This would serve to help the survival and transition of the Church when it was forced to go underground because of the great persecution which included the imprisonment of church leaders (who were predominantly male), and the destruction and closure of churches (Lewis 1994, 149). Presently, some estimate that in the underground seminary there are just as many if not more female students as male. In addition to that because of the strong leadership among the laity in the house churches some estimate that 85% of the pastoral leaders in the house churches are female (Hiebert 1982, 459). It is because of the sacrificial service of women that the House Church in China will continue to not only survive but grow and be fruitful. Stories
Xiao Min’s story is an amazing testimony of how God continues to use women in the House Church movement. Xiao Min grew up in a little farming village and neither completed Junior High School nor learned to read music, but God has used her to compose numerous Chinese hymns that are sung nationwide. She has written an estimated 930 hymns, which are appreciated by small underground house churches and professional composers alike, and have contributed to the Chinese churches ability to express their faith with indigenous songs. See a documentary on her here under The Canaan Hymns.Dreams
Christian Chinese women will continue to raise the consciousness of inequality and evil in all aspect of life through the deconstructing of imperial and patriarchal ideologies that desires to control and oppress freedom and equality; accomplishing this task by replacing the lies with truth, oppression with freedom, inequality with justice through the power of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
PRODUCTION AND CONSUMPTION
Description
The Nanjing Amity Printing Company in Nanjing China, produced 6.7 million Bibles in 2007. More than 3 million of them were for distribution in China. Today, it's a misnomer that the Chinese can only get their Bibles by smuggling them in from publishing sources outside of China. The Bibles printed at the Nanjing Amity Printing Company are printed and distributed legally within China. Some outside funding is provided to lower the cost of printing Bibles and thus lowering the price for the Chinese consumer.
In regards to other forms of Christian literature, there is more translation and publishing of books from English authors than there are resources available that originated from Chinese authors. Titles of books from Western Christianity such as The Purpose Driven Life, More Than a Carpenter, and many others are available in some independent bookstores in China as Chinese translations. However the resources are few for the publication of Christian resources produced by the Chinese House Church. Though such publications do exist, they are certainly fewer than those that are imported into China.
There are several books that have been written by members of the Chinese House Church that have been published in English and sold in the West as a testimony to its current growth and development. One of these books is called Heavenly Man, written by Brother Yun who tells his story as a Chinese House Church leader. This book has circled widely as one of the few personal testimonies coming out of China.
Stories
Ambassadors for Christ is a ministry that has served to reach out to Chinese intellectuals for 50 years. Its bookstore was established in 1981 and is the internet home of a large variety of Christian books and ministry materials that serve the needs of the Christians in Mainland China. Though its headquarters is located in Pennsylvania, its efforts are primarily directed towards China its people. Books, Bibles, training materials, as well as music and other audio/video resources are available. Many of the resources are translations from English works, but more and more are originating in China.
Dreams
The production and consumption of its own Christian literature and its own Christian resources is important for the growth and maturity of the Chinese House Church as a leader in world Christianity. For the Chinese House Church to theologize in its own context and produce materials to represent their thoughts, ideas, and beliefs would further its identity as the independent Chinese House Church, apart from the Three-Self Churches and apart from Western Christianity. Though its roots may be attributed to foreign missionaries and to the official government regulated churches and though its lacks the ability to produce its own resources, the Chinese House Church is thriving as an independent entity.
GLOBALIZATION AND Urbanization
Description 
The pace of urbanization in China from 1949 to 1982 was relatively slow because of both rapid growth of the rural population and tight restrictions on rural-urban migration. With a rationing system initiated in 1959, moving from countryside to city was virtually impossible (Starr 1997, 87). Every household had an officially registered residence, and ration coupons were issued at one’s place of residence and could only be redeemed locally. In 1978, Deng Xiaoping announced the Open Door Policy, and as a result, China began to take an active part in international affairs. Having learned from Mao’s political revolutions, Deng realized that in order to let China to be modernized, the reforms should be taken initially on the interest in the economic sector. Foreign investment was encouraged and new factories were established. Much of the effort went into developing heavy industry, such as the manufacture of machinery and metals. The construction industry has also developed quickly. Offices and apartment building, highways, and airports have been built to meet the needs of China’s huge population. (Dramer 2007, 71). The new government also allowed the return of markets, which had been banned during the Cultural Revolution (Tao 1995, 44).
Since the reform of the economic system and opening to foreign trade in 1978, China has transformed itself from an opponent to an advocate of globalization. In fact, most of China’s economic successes are associated with globalization. Today China is the country that sends mission throughout the world seeking best practice. It adapts not just foreign technology and foreign corporate management techniques but also a wide variety of foreign institutions and practices (e.g., French military acquisition systems and a central bank structure modeled on the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank) (Overholt 2005, 5). Among the most important of these changes are the decision to adopt the Western concept of rule of law, adoption of competition as a centrally important economic practice, and adoption of English language as virtually a second language for the educated Chinese population (Ibid, 5). Most importantly, China has sent its elite youth abroad for education in an exercise of internationalism.
Map of China's population density http://depts.washington.edu/chinaciv/geo/people.htm
Rapid Chinese globalization has required major adjustments. The economic reforms have initiated both rural-to-urban and west-to-east migration. In 1990’s, China’s urban population has been augmented by nearly 30 percent with the arrival of as many as 100 million migrant workers (Starr 1997, 87). Although the reform program achieved success, it also gave rise to several serious problems. State enterprise employment has declined by 44 million between 1995 and 2005, and manufacturing jobs have declined from over 54 million in 1994 to under 39 million today (Ibid, 6). Another difficulty was a wave of crime, corruption, and moral deterioration caused by the looser economic and political climate. In addition, there were tensions created by the widening income disparities between the rich and the poor. Nevertheless, because China has been willing to accept such adjustments, no large country in human history has ever
experienced such rapid improvements in living standards and working conditions. China: Urban Population | Year | 1950 | 1960 | 1970 | 1980 | 1990 | 2000 | 2005 | 2015 (prognosis) | 2030 (prognosis) |
| Urban Population (Percent) | 12.5 | 16.0 | 17.4 | 19.6 | 27.4 | 35.8 | 40.5 | 49.5 | 69.5 |
http://globalis.gvu.unu.edu/indicator_detail.cfm?IndicatorID=30&Country=CN China’s globalization has also influenced other countries. Contrary to fears, China’s rise has stimulated neighbors’ trade and foreign investment rather than depriving them. India has learned from China the advantages of a more open economy. While India started later than China and moved more slowly, India’s economic growth rates have doubled. In Asia, competition with China will force most companies to open themselves to foreign investment. China has taught others to attract foreign investment, and in response the total pool of foreign investment has greatly expanded (Ibid, 8). In addition, Chinese growth has brought American companies new markets. Inexpensive Chinese products and Chinese financing of our deficit have kept U.S. inflation and interest rates down and prolonged the economic booms.Stories
The American film industry has overpowered many national film industries in Europe and elsewhere, to the detriment of national artistic expression. The blockbuster films of Julia Roberts and Harrison Ford not only flow through an official distribution system, but videotape and DVD versions are also pirated and sold on the streets of third world cities. While several nations, including India and China, continue to produce large numbers of commercial films, even in these countries, American films are often featured on theater marquees. Yet this is only one part of the Americanization of contemporary cinema. Another side is that the grammars of other national cinemas are being transformed for distribution in America. The Chinese, for example, have bemoaned the fact that their leading directors (including Zhang Yimo and Chen kaige) make films that exoticize (or “orientalize”) Chinese culture and history for Western audiences. A recent example is Ang Lee’s Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, which won many international prizes, but reportedly was unsuccessful in mainland China. In short, Chinese felms are being tailored to American sensibilities in order to gain prestige and sale. As a result, American film culture has, at least in some senses, become world film culture. This is not to say that American cinema is not subject to diverse interpretations depending on the cultural context in which it is viewed, but only to suggest that American cultural artifacts are an increasingly central element of global culture (Ritzer 2004, 86).
"Evangelical missionaries came to China beginning in 1807, and despite the fact that most came solely to spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ, many people associated them with the evils of the colonial powers. Even in 1916, when Ruth Bell Graham's father, L. Nelson Bell, arrived with his wife, Virginia, to work at a mission hospital, many Chinese people called foreigners "foreign devils." The Bells and other missionaries had to overcome prejudice and sometimes hostility as they proclaimed and demonstrated the love of Christ" (Paulson 2008, 12).Dreams
In the early days, Christianity was predominantly isolated with little contact with those living outside of the central cities. As a result of globalization and urbanization, the growth of the church is not just among the rural poor but also the educated, urban elite. Changed policy and propaganda concerning concept of religion and a more neutral stance in education towards religious matters are creating a more positive perception of religion. Society is becoming more tolerant of religion in general, and people are becoming more open minded about their own religious beliefs. RELIGIONDescription China is currently an atheist state, meaning that the government discourages the practice of any religion. The government sees religion as a potential threat. The Chinese Constitution does, however, claim to protect freedom of worship.
Imperial China honored a rich variety of religious and philosophical traditions. Confucianism, transmitted by the teacher Confucius in the fifth century B.C., is an ethical and political philosophy that stresses hierarchy and teaches respect for authority (Chao 1989, 13). Such respect was expressed in rigid social etiquette in the family, the clan, and the nation. Daoism, indigenous to China, advocates harmony with nature and the balance of opposite forces called yin and yang (Coulson et al. 1996, 6). Daoists reject aggression, competition, and ambition. Humility and selflessness are thought to go hand in hand with the rejection of material goods, high rank, and social status. Buddhism, brought by monks from India in the first century A.D., is encouraged devotion to Buddha and characterized by compassion and charity. Islam, which arrived from central Asia in the seventh century, prolaims faith in Allah and obedience to his prophet, Muhammad (Coulson et at. 1996, 7). Intertwined with these religions and traditions is folk religion, which includes ancestor worship, spiritual healing, fortune telling, witchcraft, and geomancy (Chao, 1989, 15).Christianity in China: see History of Christianity in China sectionStories
Common testimonies (Hayward 1974, 72):“Regarding my family, we still hold prayer meeting privately. We pray at mealtimes and before going to bed. But we never do it in front of friends or neighbors. We had no Bible nor hymnal, so we didn’t sing. We had to be very careful of our actions since we shared the house with other families.”“We had family devotions at home, but not regularly. Sometimes when we gathered together, we would have devotions. Sometimes our meetings lasted two hours. We usually picked some quiet place. We spent most of the time giving testimonies. We did not practice baptism within our circle.”“This young woman, in her early twenties, had been introduced to Christ by a friend some three years ago. She said Christianity was spread from person to person by word of mouth, as no preaching is allowed, and many of her friends believed. They would baptize each other as discreetly as possible and would never dare meet together for formal worship.”
Dreams
The missionary work and foreign imperialism expanded with little regard to Chinese law or custom. China's government and Christians remember the involvement of foreign missionaries as domination over the Chinese people. A return to this hierarchical relationship would strengthen the resistance against Western Christian influence in China. Today, Chinese church leaders welcome friendly relations with churches and organizations in the West, while at the same time seeking to prevent the forcing of Western thinking and models on the Chinese church. To soften resistance, Western Christians must have an attitude of equality with the Chinese people. Moreover, the Chinese church has to become Chinese from the inside out. "As long as Christianity is understood by many as a western religion, because it has come so largely in a western form of expression, it cannot be made fully clear that as its heart there is the universal and absolute claim of the Lord Jesus Christ upon all men" (Towery 1990, 124). Western Christians in China must be a pure representation of Jesus Christ. DIASPORA, PLACE
Description
Chinese diaspora began in the fourteenth century, but the Chinese overseas population has grown tremendously in the past 60 years from 8.7 million in 1948 to over 34 million in 2002. The largest groups live in Asia (80% of the diaspora population) and North America (15%) (Wan 2003, 35). Chinese immigration to the U.S. Began in 1849, coinciding with the California gold rush. Chinese came to be miners and during the 1860s up to two-thirds of the Chinese population in America worked in California mines (Takaki 1993, 194). Early on they also worked as railroad workers and farmers (Ibid, 197-199). They were seen as good workers, honest, sober, and industrious (Ibid, 209). Jealousy provoked white workers to fight against them. Chinese were often marginalized, forced into menial labor, although often these "industrious" immigrants started their own business such as laundromats (Ibid, 201). Very few women immigrated early on due to the patriarchical system and many Chinese only planned to work in the U.S. temporarily (Ibid, 209). Today many immigrants from China and South-east Asia find themselves trapped in poverty. Lacking English skills or a high school education, a large percentage immigrants find themselves limited to low-wage jobs in New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco Chinatowns (Ibid, 415). (See Description under "Difference" and "Globalization" for discussion of the role of Place in the Chinese House Church.)Stories
Diaspora Chinese contributed to the battle for Civil Rights in the United States. According to Ronald Takaki, "contrary to the stereotype of Chinese passivity, the Chinese fought discrimination. Time and again, they took their struggle for civil rights to court. Believing that the Chinese should be entitled to citizenship, they challenged the 1790 Naturalization Law. In 1855, Chan Yong applied for citizenship in San Francisco's federal district court. The local newspapers noted that Chan Yong was more 'white' in appearance that most Chinese. The court denied him citizenship, however, ruling that the 1790 law restricted citizenship to 'whites' and that the Chinese were not 'white.' Seven years later, Ling Sing sued the San Francisco tax collector, challenging the $2.50 head tax levied on Chinese. In Ling Sing v. Washburn, the California Supreme Court ruled that while the Chinese could be taxed as other residents, they could not be set apart for special taxation. Significantly in this case, the state law was invalidated on the grounds that it violated the United States Constitution" (Takaki 1993, 207).
Dreams
Enoch Wan has noted two important mission trends among the diaspora Chinese. First, coming from Communist China or (largely) Buddhist Taiwan, these emigrants are receptive to the gospel. The most critical need for these Chinese, as for their brothers and sisters in Mainland China, is for leadership and discipleship (Wan 2003, 37). The second trend is an increased mission participation of diaspora Chinese churches. From 1980 to 2000 the number of Chinese missionaries increased ten-fold from approximately 100-1000 (Ibid, 37). A tremendous potential exists for partnership in mission between the Church of the West and these diaspora Christians, whose dream it is to see the gospel proclaimed in the country of their ethnic heritage.
LANGUAGE, BODY & PERFORMANCE
Description
Language:
According to information published in China in 1988, the 55 minority groups use 78 languages other than Chinese. Some of these languages have a written script, but more than half do not. Aside form the 78 minority languages mentioned above, several hundred sub-languages and dialects are included under the label “Chinese.” Communication between speakers of many of the Chinese dialects is only possible because of the existence of an official national language, Putonghua, the “common speech,” more commonly known in English as Mandarin. Yet even this language, which is based on the Beijing dialect, the language of the civil service in imperial times, differs greatly in the way it is spoken from place to place (Chaos 1989, 6). One common thread in China that may help overcome this obstacle is that the English language is highly sought after. It is through this channel that many English speaking missionary are allowed access to the young people of China. Although missionary workers are not permitted in China, many missionaries come to China as English teachers with the hopes of building relationship with their student outside of the classroom where they can share their faith. The English Language Institute, China (
ELIC), is one of the biggest agencies which train and sends out teachers to China. While authorities are aware of these tactics, because of the quality and character of the teachers they have allowed this form of missionary work to continue (Aikman 2003, 279).
Body:
The Chinese house churches do not in any way discriminate against foreigners to join their fellowship, yet, for precautionary measures foreigners who do not have distinct physical Chinese characteristics are discouraged to worship in some of the house church meetings. Persecution is still a real threat to the house churches and those who look Western may draw unwanted attention to the meetings.
Many of the top leaders of the Chinese house churches have undergone some type of physical punishment for their involvement with the house church movement. Some of these punishments include beatings, imprisonment, and
re-education through labor. These house church believers carry with them physically this shared experience of suffering for Christ with the belief that they will one day reign with Jesus (Aikman 2003, 94). Efforts have been made to have those currently imprisoned for their belief to be released by some of the top leaders in the larger house church networks. In August of 1998 house church leaders collaborated to put together a document called the “
United Appeal of the Various Branches of the Chinese House Church” to be published in the West and transmitted back to China in the hopes of the Government loosening their grip on the house church movement (Aikman 2003, 90).
Performance: Since the Chinese House Church movement covers such a wide range of believers without denominational distinctions it is difficult to pinpoint one distinguishing expression of faith that would characterize it. However, there is estimated one-half to two-thirds of the house churches belonging to the charismatic movement. Their expression of faith includes praying out loud (which may be accompanied by weeping out loud), praying in tongues, prophecy, healing, worship through dancing and hand waving and other forms of spiritual expressions. (Aikman 2003 136). In an attempt to bring some cohesion and clarity on what the house churches believed, on November 1998 there was a gathering of leaders from some of the largest house church networks that put together a
confession of faith document. In this statement it clarifies that the house churches do not believe in the cessation of the spiritual gifts but one does not have to speak in tongues to authenticate their salvation (Aikman 2003 92-93).
Stories
As the late China historian John K. Fairbank noted, "the Christian missionaries struggle against many obstacles, including the Chinese language. The missionaries needed terminology to convey their message. China already had a distinctive theological vocabulary to designate God, the soul, sin, repentance, and salvation. Therefore if the missionaries used established terms, usually derived from Buddhism, the message could not be delivered correctly. They struggled even to come up with a term for God. After much discussion, the Catholics chose the term Tianzhu (Lord of Heaven), while Protestants used Shangdi (Supreme God or Heavenly King), Shen (God), or Zhu (Lord)" (Coulson 1996, 9).
Dreams
That the Gospel will continue to powerfully spread throughout China both indigenously and through foreign missionary by the transcended power of the spirit which can overcome any language barrier. China’s Government would readjust their policies and laws so that they would not fight against what God is trying to do in China. The Government would release those in prison for their faith, as well as recognize and legally allowed house churches to meet for worship. That foreign missionary influence would not steer the indigenous form of worship towards any kind of form. Rather the house churches will continue to grow in her ability to express her faith in an authentic way that honors God.
CONCLUSION
Chinese house churches are no longer hidden. A new generation of house churches in the cities is becoming more confident in establishing constructive dialogue with the government. A number of house churches are actively seeking registration with the government, and many hope to be registered separately from the official Three Self Patriotic Movement.
Chinese Christians are seeking to redefine Chinese nationalism in a way that incorporates the Christian faith, with the belief that Christians serve a vital role in Chinese society.
Also, young intellectual Christians love China and hope to have positive influence on the country with Christian values and love. This calls for an open and inclusive government to accommodate them!
It is the dream of the Chinese house churches to share the Gospel with as many fellow Chinese as possible. Brothers and sisters of house churches are the light in the society, especially when morality is declining, injustice is prevailing, and people are losing hope in what they previously believed.REFERENCES
Aikman, David. 2003. Jesus in Beijing. Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing, Inc.
Adeney, David H. 1985. China: The Church’s Long March. Ventura: Regal Books.
Bays, Daniel H. 1996. The Growth of Independent Christianity in China, 1900-1937. In Christianity in China: From the Eighteenth Century to the Present, edited by D. H. Bays. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
___. 2003a. Chinese Protestant Christianity Today. The China Quarterly. 174 (June 2003): 497-98.
___. 2003b. Foreign Mission and Indigenous Protestant Leaders in China, 1920-1955: Identity and Loyalty in an Age of Powerful Nationalism. In Missions, Nationalism, and the End of Empire, edited by B. Stanley. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
Brandner, Tobias. 2004. Jianshe Theology: Reflections about the Process of Theological Reconstruction in China. International Review of Mission (April 2004):199-209.
Chao, Jonathan. 1989. The China Mission Handbook: A Portrait of China and its Church. Hong Kong: Chinese Church Research Center.
Cheng, May M.C. 2003. House Church Movements and Religious Freedom in China. China: An International Journal 1 (1):16-45.
Covell, Ralph. R. 2001. Christianity and China's Minority Nationalities - Faith and Unbelief. China and Christianity: Burdened Past, Hopeful Future. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
Coulson, Gail V, Christopher Herlinger, and Camille S. Anders. 1996. The Enduring Church: Christians in China and Hong Kong. New York: Friendship Press.
Domes, Jürgen. 1977. China After the Cultural Revolution. Translated by A. Berg and D. Goodman. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Dramer, Kim. 2007. People’s Republic of China Enchantment of the World. New York: Scholastic.
Dube, Musa W. 2006. Reading for Decolonization (John 4:1-42). In Voices from the Margin: Interpreting the Bible in the Thirld World, edited by R. S. Sugirtharajah. Mary Knoll, New York: Orbis Books.
Esherick, Joseph, et al. 2006. The Chinese Cultural Revolution as History: An Introduction. In The Chinese Cultural Revolutions as History, edited by J. W. Esherick, et al. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Fanon, Frantz. 1995. National Culture. In The Post-Colonial Studies Reader, edited by G. G. Bill Ashcroft, Helen Tiffin. London: Routledge.
Gao, Wanzhi. 1996. Y.T. Wu: A Christian Leader Under Communism. In Christianity in China: From the Eighteenth Century to the Present, edited by D. H. Bays. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Gonzalez, Justo L. 1985. The Reformation to the Present Day. Vol. 2, The Story of Christianity. New York: Harper San Francisco.
Gunde, Richard. 2002. Culture and Customs of China. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Publishing Group.
Hayward, Victor E. W. 1974. Christians and China. Belfast: Christian Journals Limited.
Hiebert, Frances. 1982. Missionary Women as Models in the Cross-Cultural Context. In Missiology l0:4, 459-460.
Ho, Dahpon David. 2006. To Protect and Preserve: Resisting the Destry the Four Olds Campaign, 1966-1967. In The Chinese Cultural Revolution as History, edited by J. W. Esherick, et al. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Katrak, Ketu H. 1995. Decolonizing Culture: Toward a Theory for Postcolonial Women's Text. In The Post-Colonial Studies Reader, edited by G. G. Bill Ashcroft, Helen Tiffin. London: Routledge.
Kwok, Pui-Lan. 1988. Feminist Theology from a Chinese Perspective. In Towards a Chinese Feminist Theology. Edited by Winnie Ho. Hong Kong: Lutheran Theological Seminary.
___. 1996. Chinese Women and Protestant Christianity at the Turn of the Twentieth Century. In Christianity in China From the Eighteenth Century to the Present. Edited by Daniel H. Bays. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Lambert, Tony. 2003. Counting Christians in China: A cautionary report. In International Bulletin of Missionary Research 27 (1):6-10.
Lawrence, Carl. 1985. The Church in China: How it Survives and Prospers Under Communism. Minneapolis: Bethany House Publishers.
Lee, Archie C.C. 2006. Returning to China: Biblical Interpretation in Postcolonial Hong Kong. In Voices from the Margin: Interpreting the Bible in the Third World, edited by R. S. Sugirtharajah. Mary Knoll, New York: Orbis Books.
Lewis, Rebecca. 2004. Proceedings of the ISFM 2004 Meeting: Insider Movements Underground Church Movements: The Surprising Role of Women’s Networks. In International Journal of Frontier Missions Winter 2004: William Carey International University. <http://www.ijfm.org/PDFs_IJFM/21_4_PDFs/Role_of_Women.pdf > )
Liu, Brother. 2008. 北京本地家庭教会报告. In 生命季刊杂志, (January, 2008).
MacInnis, Donald E. 1989. Religion in China Today: Policy and Practice. Mary Knoll, New York: Orbis Books.
Ng, Sonia. 1988. Women in Traditional Chinese Society. In Towards A Chinese Feminist Theology. Edited by Winnie Ho. Translated by Craig Moran. Hong Kong: Lutheran Theological Seminar.
Overholt, William H. 2005. China and Globalization. Santa Monica: RAND Corporation. (May 19, 2005).
Paulson, Bob. 2008. Pain of the Past, Faith for the Future. Billy Graham Evangelistic Association. 49 (7/8): 11-13.
Peterson, Kirsten H. 1995. First Things First: Problems of a Feminist Approach to African Literature. In The Post-Colonial Studies Reader, edited by G. G. Bill Ashcroft, Helen Tiffin. London: Routledge.
Riley, Jennifer. 2008. China's Gov't-Approved Church Reaches Out to House Churches. Christianpost. November 9, 2008.
Ritzer, George. 2004. The Globalization of Nothing. Thousand Oaks: Pine Forge Press.
Simons, Craig. 2008. Bibles Abound in China. The News and Observer. August 8, 2008.
Sing, Andrew Chi. 2005. Toward a Contextual Theology of Suffering: The Chinese Christian Perspective Since 1949. A Dissertation Presented to Fuller Theological Seminary, November 2004. UMI Number: 3180569 (ProQuest Information and Learning Company: Ann Arbor, MI, 2005).
Sons of Heaven. 2008. The Economist. http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=12342509 accessed Nov 5.
Starr, John Bryan. 1997. Understanding China: A Guide to China’s Economy, History, and Political Structure. New York: Hill and Wang.
Suen, Brother. 2007. 認識中國城市家庭教會. In 時代論壇 . 1020 (March 18, 2007) http://christiantimes.org.hk/Common/Reader/News/ShowNews.jsp?Nid=39965&Pid=2&Version=1020&Cid=575&Charset=big5_hkscs
Takaki, Ronald. 1993. A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. New York: Back Bay Books.
Tao, Wang. 1995. Exploration into China. Parsippany, New Jersey: New Discovery Books.
Towery, Britt. 1990. Churches of China: Taking Root Downward, Bearing Fruit Upward. Texas: Baylor University.
Wan, Enoch. 2003. Mission among the Chinese Diaspora: A Case Study of Migration and Mission. Missiology, 31(1): 35-43.
Wang, Jiali. 1997. The House Church Movement: A Participant’s Assessment. Word & World, 17(2), Spring 2007.
Yip, Ka-Che. 2003. China and Christianity: Perspectives on Mission, Nationalism and the State in the Republican Period, 1912-1949. In Missions, Nationalism and the End of Empire. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
Zeng, Xing Fu. 2006. 中國知識份子與基督教信仰 (Chinese Intellectuals and Christian Faith). Christian Study Centre on Chinese Religion and Culture Journal. Issue 13. November 2006.
Zhu, Xundao. 中国城市新兴教会初探, (Wenzhou, Zhejiang), http://www.chinaeforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=1212